Custom Cookies, Cakes and more!

At Samantha's Sweet Shoppe, we specialize in making beautiful, delicious custom cookies, cakes and desserts perfectly tailored for your family celebrations, birthdays, weddings and corporate events. Best of all, we bring the sweetness straight to your door with convenient delivery throughout the greater Cincinnati area.


Sweet Treats Made-To-Order


Ready to order?
Click the button below to get started.


Welcome to our sweet shoppe!
We’re so glad you’re here.


My name is Samantha, and baking has always been a true passion of mine. As a wife, mom, and baker, I founded Samantha’s Sweet Shoppe, LLC alongside my husband, Zachary, in 2023 with the goal of bringing beautiful, delicious, handcrafted desserts to families and celebrations throughout the greater Cincinnati area.Before starting our business, I spent years working in bakeries for larger companies, where I gained valuable experience and refined my skills in baking and dessert design. Today, every order we create is handmade-to-order with care, creativity, and attention to detail. Whether you’re celebrating a birthday, wedding, baby shower, holiday, or simply treating yourself, we strive to make each dessert unique and personalized to fit your vision and needs.We currently operate as an at-home cottage bakery and proudly follow all guidelines set by the Ohio Department of Agriculture. We are committed to providing products that are not only beautiful and delicious, but also safe, fresh, and made with the highest level of care.Thank you so much for visiting our website and supporting our small family business. We truly appreciate every order and look forward to being part of your special moments!


As Featured in the "Sweets" Issue of Cincinnati Magazine


Cincinnati Magazine reached out to Samantha's Sweet Shoppe and was asked to feature its brownies in their October 2024 "Sweets" issue; we happily accepted!Check out their "Guide to Brownies" here.


The Great Cincinnati Bake-Off


Samantha's Sweet Shoppe was invited to be a part of Cincinnati Magazine's annual event held on October 8, 2024 where roughly 450 people sampled our brownies, cookies, and chocolate-dipped Oreos.We also made it briefly on the FOX19 news!
Check out the screenshots below.


Testimonials


"Every dessert is made with love, and every purchase helps an amazing family with their small business! They do delivery as well!"

"Samantha's Sweet Shoppe is so refreshingly delicious! Very happy to find a bakery that makes all their baked goods scrumptious!"

"I will not be ordering cakes from anywhere else!"

"If you want an amazing cake for your special occasion this is the place."

"The chocolate brownies with the chocolate ganache icing/frosting... OMG SO AMAZING!"

"Samantha made a cake and cookies for my bachelorette party and bridal shower and they turned out perfect! I had sent her a couple inspo pics and the desserts were spot on! Everything also tasted great and got a lot of compliments from friends and guests!"

"Samantha did a great job with the vision we had for this retirement party. We had so many compliments from guests on how good the cake, cupcakes, and cake pops were. Thank you Samantha and Zach!"


Click the button below to see more testimonials from our happy customers and to leave one of your own.

Contact Us / Location


Ready to order?
Click the button below to get started.


Need to make a payment?
Click the button below to pay.


Reach out to let us know if there is anything we can do for you or to answer any questions.


Local delivery is available throughout the greater Cincinnati area. Pickup is available from our house in Colerain off I-275.Address:
Samantha's Sweet Shoppe, LLC
10658 Pottinger Road
Cincinnati, Ohio 45251

Testimonials

Check out our customer reviews/feedback below and share your own experience! We love hearing how we're doing—and reviews on Yelp or Google really help us out the most.



Policies, Terms and Conditions


Satisfaction Guarantee & Refunds
At Samantha's Sweet Shoppe, we strive to make every order perfect and in doing so, we guarantee you will like it or you will get your money back (minus your deposit). However, once an order has been accepted by the customer, we are no longer liable for any damages or mishaps to the order. The customer also accepts that the design of the order is as expected at this time. It is the customer's responsibility to check the order for correctness. If anything is wrong prior to the customer accepting the order, we will be happy to fix it and make it right to the best of our ability or issue a refund. Please contact us if you have any questions or concerns.
Allergens
Please mention at the time of order if you have any allergies. We will do our best to avoid cross-contamination, but cannot guarantee it will be completely avoided. The customer accepts this possibility by proceeding with the order. No refunds will be issued if the customer fails to mention any allergies after the order has been accepted.
Deposits & Payments
A portion of the total price of the order is expected as a deposit at the time of order placement and will be applied towards the final price. If an order is placed less than 7 days from the scheduled pickup or delivery date, the order must be paid in full. If the order is for more than $200, the order must be paid in full. If the order is to be delivered, the order must be paid in full. Deposits and final payments can be paid via the "Payment" page on our website or by calling us directly at (513) 549-7441. Please do not send credit card information over text, email, or social media. We are not responsible for identity theft or stolen credit card information. The remaining balance of the order is expected at the time of order pickup or delivery. We accept cash, all major credit cards, Apple Pay, Google G Pay, Cash App, Venmo, and Zelle.
Store Pickup & Deliveries
Pickup from our store is always free (and encouraged) as we are able to fix most things prior to the acceptance of an order. Once the order has been accepted by the customer and paid for, we are no longer liable or responsible for any mistakes or damages. If an order is not picked up within 2 hours of the scheduled pickup time, the order may no longer be available for pickup and will not be refunded.
Local delivery is available for a fee, dependent on the distance from Samantha's Sweet Shoppe. All orders are personally delivered. If no one is at the address to receive the order, we will call or email to inform that we are there to deliver. Unless instructed otherwise, the delivery will be left at the home or business address as indicated at the time of order. It is your responsibility to let the recipient know that the order will be arriving that day.
Cancellations
A minimum of 7 days is needed to prepare an item. We make everything to order and do not have anything prepared ahead of time. Once an item is ordered, it can not be cancelled if within 7 days of the scheduled pickup or delivery date. A percentage of the total price of the order is expected as a deposit at the time of order and will not be refunded if the order is cancelled less than 7 days before scheduled pickup or delivery time. The deposit will be refunded in full minus any fees from Cash App, Venmo, or if paid via credit card through Square if cancelled 7 days or more from scheduled pickup or delivery (if applicable).

Thank you for your business!

Order Request Form


Order Request Received.

Thank you for submitting your order request form. We truly appreciate you taking the time to support a small business like ours—it means a lot! Your request is important to us, and we’ll review it as soon as possible.

What happens next?

  1. We'll review your request to confirm availability for the date and time provided and ensure we have all the details we need.

  2. We'll reach out to you via the preferred contact method you chose within 24-48 hours to discuss final details and to receive a quoted price.
    Please note: Your oder isn't officially locked into our schedule until payment is processed. Payments can be made via our website, over the phone, or in person if the price is accepted.


If you have any questions, please contact us.

Make a Payment

Select your preferred option below to make a payment. Pay securely with debit/credit cards, Apple Pay, and Google G Pay. Venmo, Cash App, or Zelle also accepted. Prefer a human touch? You can also select the phone option to speak with us directly.


Cards & Mobile Wallets
Secure, instant processing with automated email receipts processed by Square.

Mobile Payment Apps
Please include your full name and email address in the app's payment note so we can manually match your transaction and send your confirmation.

[email protected]

Search our email address within your banking app to pay with Zelle.


Pay by Phone
Call us directly at (513) 549-7441 to securely process your order over the phone.

Cash
Cash is accepted for pickup orders and for delivery orders paid, in full, in advance only. Please have as close to exact change as possible. We cannot guarantee we'll be able to break large bills.

Thank you for your payment.

Your payment has been successfully processed, and your order is officially on our calendar. Thank you for supporting a small business. We can't wait to share our sweets with you!

If you have any questions, please contact us.

Cookies

From classic, crowd-pleasing chocolate chip to custom, hand-decorated designs tailored to your vision, we bring your sweet ideas to life. We can even feature your favorite photos or business logos directly on your cookies. Whatever the occasion, our one-of-a-kind cookies are guaranteed to leave a lasting impression at your next event.

Edible Image Cookies

  • Pricing starting at $4/cookie

  • Sugar cookies made-to-order from scratch

  • Hand-piped white base with our speciality royalty icing

  • Your image of choice printed directly onto the cookies with GMP-certified edible ink

  • Individually bagged at no extra cost (per your request)

Traditional Cookies

  • Pricing starting at $5/cookie

  • Sugar cookies made-to-order from scratch

  • Hand-piped and decorated with our speciality royalty icing

  • Individually bagged at no extra cost (per your request)

Classic Cookies

  • Pricing starting at $30/dozen

  • Cookies made-to-order from scratch

  • Available flavors:

  • Chocolate

  • Chocolate chip / chunk

  • Sugar

  • White chocolate macadamia nut

  • Oatmeal

  • Peanut butter

  • Chocolate candy pieces (M&Ms)

  • Can be made into cookie sandwiches in your color of choice with our signature icing types and flavors:

  • Buttercream

  • Chocolate buttercream**

  • Whipped

  • Chocolate whipped**

*Pricing breakdowns available upon request. Price fluctuates depending on design. Any flavors not mentioned above may be available upon request.

**Chocolate icing types only available in brown color.


Ready to order?
Click the button below to get started.


Please note: A minimum of 7 days is needed to prepare an item. We make everything to order and do not have anything prepared ahead of time. Once an item is ordered, it can be cancelled within 2 days of the scheduled pickup or delivery date. Please review all policies prior to placing an order.

Cakes

Celebrate life's sweetest moments with the perfect cake. Choose from nine delicious flavors—including red velvet, marble, and funfetti—and pair it with our signature buttercream or decadent chocolate icings. Add a personal touch with a custom edible image to bring your celebration to life.

Sheet Cakes

  • Pricing starting at:

  • 1/4 sheet: $35

  • 1/2 sheet: $60

  • Full sheet: $120

Round Cakes

  • Pricing starting at:

  • 5" (baby smash cake): $15

  • 6": $35

  • 8": $45

  • 10": $60

2-Tiered Cakes

  • Pricing starting at $150

*Pricing breakdowns available upon request. Price fluctuates depending on design.

Cake Flavors

  • White (vanilla)

  • Chocolate

  • Yellow

  • Marble

  • Red velvet

  • Strawberry

  • Lemon

  • Funfetti

  • Almond

Icing Types & Flavors

  • Buttercream

  • Chocolate buttercream**

  • Whipped

  • Chocolate whipped**

  • Cream cheese

Filling Types & Flavors

  • Vanilla

  • Chocolate

  • Strawberry

  • Lemon

  • Cookies & cream (Oreo)

  • Peanut butter

*Any flavors not mentioned above may be available upon request. If requesting an edible image (additional fee), please make sure to upload your picture when ordering.

**Chocolate icing types only available in brown color.


Ready to order?
Click the button below to get started.


Please note: A minimum of 7 days is needed to prepare an item. We make everything to order and do not have anything prepared ahead of time. Once an item is ordered, it can be cancelled within 2 days of the scheduled pickup or delivery date. Please review all policies prior to placing an order.

Cupcakes

Indulge in our handcrafted cupcakes and custom cupcake cakes, available in a variety of delicious flavors—including chocolate, yellow, marble, red velvet, funfetti, and more. Pair your favorite base with our signature rich buttercream or whipped icing for the perfect treat.

Traditional

  • Pricing starting at $35/dozen

  • Your choice of cake flavor(s):

  • White (vanilla)

  • Chocolate

  • Yellow

  • Marble

  • Red velvet

  • Strawberry

  • Lemon

  • Funfetti

  • Almond

  • Your choice of icing color(s) and type(s) with or without sprinkles:

  • Buttercream

  • Chocolate buttercream**

  • Whipped

  • Chocolate whipped**

  • Cream cheese

Decorated & Specialty

  • Pricing starting at $45/dozen

  • Your choice of cake flavor(s) with your choice of icing color(s) and type(s) in your requested design

  • Additionally for specialty cupcakes, we offer fillings and toppings:

  • Vanilla

  • Chocolate

  • Strawberry

  • Lemon

  • Cookies & cream (Oreo)

  • Peanut butter

Cupcake Cakes

  • Pricing starting at $45/dozen

  • Your choice of cake flavor(s), icing color(s) and type(s), and optional fillings and toppings in your requested design

  • Edible image available

*Pricing breakdowns available upon request. Price fluctuates depending on design. Any flavors not mentioned above may be available upon request. If requesting an edible image (additional fee), please make sure to upload your picture when ordering.

**Chocolate icing types only available in brown color.


Ready to order?
Click the button below to get started.


Please note: A minimum of 7 days is needed to prepare an item. We make everything to order and do not have anything prepared ahead of time. Once an item is ordered, it can be cancelled within 2 days of the scheduled pickup or delivery date. Please review all policies prior to placing an order.

Cake Pops

Delight in our bite-sized cake pops, the perfect pop-in-your-mouth treat for any gathering. Each one features our signature moist cake—available in chocolate, red velvet, strawberry, funfetti and more—dipped in a smooth candy coating. Customize your finish with your choice of colorful sprinkles, shimmering edible glitter, or a classic chocolate drizzle to make your event truly pop.

Traditional

  • Pricing starting at $21/dozen

  • Your choice of cake flavor(s):

  • White (vanilla)

  • Chocolate

  • Yellow

  • Marble

  • Red velvet

  • Strawberry

  • Lemon

  • Funfetti

  • Your choice of chocolate flavor(s) and color(s):

  • White chocolate

  • Semi-sweet chocolate**

  • Individually bagged at no extra cost (per your request)

Decorated

  • Pricing starting at $30/dozen

  • Your choice of cake flavor(s) and choice of chocolate color(s) in your requested design

  • Individually bagged at no extra cost (per your request)

  • Decorated examples include:

  • Different shapes (heart-shaped, golf balls, etc.)

  • Sprinkles, edible glitter

  • Chocolate drizzle

*Pricing breakdowns available upon request. Price fluctuates depending on design. Any flavors not mentioned may be available upon request.

**Chocolate flavor only available in brown color.


Ready to order?
Click the button below to get started.


Please note: A minimum of 7 days is needed to prepare an item. We make everything to order and do not have anything prepared ahead of time. Once an item is ordered, it can be cancelled within 2 days of the scheduled pickup or delivery date. Please review all policies prior to placing an order.

Brownies

Savor our decadent, fudgy brownies and custom brownie cakes, baked to perfection for a rich, melt-in-your-mouth experience. Choose your favorite base, customize it with our signature buttercream or whipped icing, and add the perfect finishing touch with your choice of sprinkles, crunchy walnuts, M&Ms, Oreo pieces and more.

Traditional

  • Pricing starting at $35/dozen

  • Cut into squares with no icing or toppings

Decorated & Specialty

  • Pricing starting at $40/dozen

  • Cut into squares

  • Your choice of icing color(s) and type(s):

  • Plain (no icing)

  • Buttercream

  • Chocolate buttercream**

  • Whipped

  • Chocolate whipped**

  • Chocolate ganache**

  • Your choice of topping(s):

  • Plain (no toppings)

  • Walnut pieces

  • Sprinkles

  • Chocolate candy pieces (M&Ms)

  • Oreo cookie pieces

Brownie Cakes

  • Pricing starting at:

  • 8x8" square:

  • $35 (plain)

  • $40 (icing + toppings)

  • 1/4 sheet:

  • $40 (plain)

  • $45 (icing + toppings)

  • Your choice of icing color(s) and type in your requested design with your choice of toppings

  • Edible image available

*Pricing breakdowns available upon request. Price fluctuates depending on design. Any flavors not mentioned above may be available upon request. If requesting an edible image (additional fee), please make sure to upload your picture when ordering.

**Chocolate icing types only available in brown color.


Ready to order?
Click the button below to get started.


Please note: A minimum of 7 days is needed to prepare an item. We make everything to order and do not have anything prepared ahead of time. Once an item is ordered, it can be cancelled within 2 days of the scheduled pickup or delivery date. Please review all policies prior to placing an order.

Chocolate-Dipped Sweets

Elevate your dessert spread with our delightful chocolate-dipped treats, featuring crunchy Oreos, pretzels, crisp wafer cookies, and gooey rice krispies treats. Each item is hand-dipped in premium chocolate and can be finished with your choice of colorful sprinkles or an elegant chocolate drizzle for a beautiful, sweet touch.

Sweets & Treats

  • Pricing starting at:

  • Buckeyes: $30

  • Oreo cookies: $30

  • Pretzels: $25

  • Wafer cookies: $20

  • Rice Krispies Treats: $30

  • Strawberries: $50

  • Individually bagged at no extra cost (per your request)

Chocolate Flavors

  • Your choice of chocolate flavor(s) and color(s):

  • White chocolate

  • Semi-sweet chocolate**

  • Dark chocolate**

  • Milk chocolate**

Toppings

  • Your choice of topping(s):

  • Plain (no toppings)

  • Chocolate drizzle

  • Sprinkles

*Pricing breakdowns available upon request. Price fluctuates depending on design. Any flavors not mentioned above may be available upon request.

**Chocolate flavors only available in brown color.


Ready to order?
Click the button below to get started.


Please note: A minimum of 7 days is needed to prepare an item. We make everything to order and do not have anything prepared ahead of time. Once an item is ordered, it can be cancelled within 2 days of the scheduled pickup or delivery date. Please review all policies prior to placing an order.